Derrick
A few points that occur to me:
1. I note from your first message that your initial request was on 21 Feb and DEFRA replied on 31 Mar. That's 28 working days. They are obliged to have replied within 20 working days:
Quote:A public authority must inform the applicant in writing whether it holds the information requested and if so, communicate that information to the applicant, promptly,
but not later than 20 working days after receipt of the request. [FOI Act, s10(1)]
The Access Code 1 gives further guidance to public authorities on the 20 working day time limit. Part IV, paragraph 17 of the Code states that:
‘Public authorities are required to comply with all requests for information promptly and they should not delay responding until the end of the 20 working day period under section 10(1) if the information could reasonably have been provided earlier.’
[emphasis in original]
http://www.ico.gov.uk/documentUploads/AG%2011Time%20for%20compliance.pdf (Question 1)
So DEFRA have already failed in their legal obligations.
2. If the section of DEFRA that you sent the request to was not able to answer all the questions, then they should have forwarded to the relevant section promptly - and you should still have received an answer within the original 20 day time limit. It is not a valid excuse that they have only just forwarded the request to another section.
Quote:A request is ‘received’ when it is delivered to the public authority, or when it is delivered to the inbox of a member of staff. The date of receipt is not the date the request is passed to the appropriate person for processing.
...
It is in the interests of the public authority to ensure that mail is distributed, and acted upon, romptly. Public authorities will also need to give thought to their procedures for dealing with communications, where an addressee is ... absent ...
ibid, Q.3
3. It sounds as if they didn't acknowledge your original or subsequent requests:
Quote:It would be good practice to acknowledge receipt of requests and to refer to the 20 working day time limit, so that applicants know their request is being dealt with. It would also be good practice to let applicants know when they might expect a full response.
ibid, Q.3
4. If they refuse to disclose any requested information, they must issue a Refusal Notice within the 20 day time limit. It appears that they have not done that!
Quote:Where the authority is relying on one or more of the exemptions and is withholding information, it must issue a Refusal Notice (under section 17 of the Act) within the same timeframe, specifying the exemption and why it applies.
ibid, Q.7
5. If they fail to respond within the time limit, they should be reported to the Information Commissioner even if the information has since been supplied, so that he can see whether there is a consistent failure to repond within the time limit and advise the authority accordingly.
Quote:
Failure to respond within the time limit would be a breach of s10 of the Act. In the event of a complaint by an applicant that he/she had received a late response to a request, the Information Commissioner would record that fact in his Decision Notice, but there would be no practical consequence, as the information had been received in the meantime.
The Information Commissioner will take into account all the circumstances of the case, when specifying in his Decision Notice, what steps the authority should take in order to comply with s10.
The Information Commissioner has a general duty under s47 of the Act to promote good practice. Should he become aware of a consistent failure to respond to requests within the time limit, he may issue an Enforcement Notice.
ibid, Q.10
In my hunble opinion, they are either in total ignorance of the law, or are totally disregarding it.
So, personally, I would be inclined to follow up with them - the fact that they have just sent a request to another section is not a valid excuse, and you could be waiting another 28 working days or more!
I would also simultaneously to report them to the Information Commissioner for failure to respond in time, and for failure to answer ALL the questions.