|
Well I have finally got a decision from the ICO, and guess what? it goes in NHS Directs favour, although not 100%, Here are the 2 main pages from the decision,the info runs to 18 A4 sheets and actually believes the lies that NHS Direct put out re section 38 of the act,(Health & Safety). Reference: FS500******* Freedom of Information Act 2000 (Section 50) Decision Notice Date: 30 July 2007 Public Authority: NHS Direct Address: Marlborough Court Sunrise Parkway Linford Wood East Milton Keynes MK146DY Complainant: Address: Summary The complainant sought disclosure of the geographic telephone numbers for NHS Direct. NHS Direct refused to disclose the information on the basis that it was exempt by virtue of section 22 (future publication), section 38 (health and safety) and section 44 (prohibition on disclosure). Following correspondence with the Commissioner it withdrew the application of section 44. Having considered the complaint the Commissioner decided that the information was not exempt under section 22. However he decided that section 38 was engaged and that the public interest in maintaining the exemption outweighed the public interest in disclosure. The Commissioner also concluded that the public authority had breached section 1 of the Act by incorrectly claiming the information was not held and that it had breached the requirements of section 17 of the Act by failing to issue an adequate refusal notice. The Commissioner's Role 1. The Commissioner's duty is to decide whether a request for information made to a public authority has been dealt with in accordance with the requirements of Part 1 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (the "Act"). This Notice sets out his decision. Reference: FS500****** The Decision 63. The Commissioner has decided that NHS Direct failed to comply with section 1(1 )(a) of the Act by initially incorrectly claiming that it did not hold the geographic numbers. 64. Furthermore, the Commissioner has decided that NHS Direct has breached section 17(1) of the Act by failing to specify in its refusal notice the exemptions it was relying on and why it applied. 65. The Commissioner has also decided NHS Direct has breached section 17(7) of the Act by failing to provide details of its complaints procedure or explain the right to complain to the Information Commissioner. 66. The Commissioner has also decided that NHS Direct incorrectly applied section 22 of the Act. 67. However the Commissioner's decision is that the information requested is exempt under section 38 of the Act because disclosure of the information would or would be likely to endanger the health and safety of individuals and the public interest favours maintaining the exemption. Steps Required 68. The Commissioner requires no steps to be taken. So I nearly got it in my favour, but at the moment they are winning, as I said above the decision runs to 18 A4 pages, and as yet is not showing on the ICO's website so I cannot link to it, I am happy to forward it in an e-mail,( but that might have to be over several e-mails re how much my hrovider will allow over the net at one time), to anyone who would like to look at it and suggest, (in a PM, as they are aware of this site and this thread), anything I could put to an appeal against the decision, I have 28 calendar days to lodge such an appeal, also notice in the appeal details the contact number,(despite their "condemnation" in the decision of 0845 numbers by public bodies), their contact number is an 0845!! Reference: FS500****** Right of Appeal 69. Either party has the right to appeal against this Decision Notice to the Information Tribunal. Information about the appeals process may be obtained from: Information Tribunal Arnhem House Support Centre PO Box 6987 Leicester LE1 6ZX Tel: 0845 600 0877 Fax: 01162494253 Email: informationtribunakS^dca. gsi.gov.uk Any Notice of Appeal should be served on the Tribunal within 28 calendar days of the date on which this Decision Notice is served. Dated the 30th day of July 2007 Signed ......^.l.t^P^y4^..... Richard Thomas Information Commissioner Information Commissioner's Office Wycliffe House Water Lane Wilmslow Cheshire SK9 5AF
|